What is Keyword Cannibalization and 4 Simple Steps to Fix it

What is Keyword Cannibalization and 4 Simple Steps to Fix it

What is Keyword Cannibalization and 4 Simple Steps to Fix it

As Seen On

Imagine you’re a chef in a bustling kitchen. You’ve got multiple dishes going, each vying for the spotlight. That’s your website. Each dish is a page. Now, imagine if all your dishes started to taste the same. Confusing, right? This is the essence of keyword cannibalization in the world of SEO. Still too vague? Well read on to find out what is keyword cannibalization in-depth.

What Is Keyword Cannibalization And How To Fix It With Simple Steps?

Key Takeaway: The One-Pot Wonder

To avoid the pitfalls of keyword cannibalization:

  • Treat your website like a well-organized kitchen. Each page (dish) should have its unique flavour (keyword).
  • Regularly audit your website’s content. It’s like checking your pots – are they complementing each other or competing?
  • When you find overlapping content, think of it as blending similar ingredients. Combine them to create a richer, more flavorful dish (page).

What is Keyword Cannibalization?

Keyword cannibalization occurs when multiple pages on your website target the same or similar keywords. It leads to a situation where your own pages compete against each other in search rankings, diluting the effectiveness of your SEO efforts. It’s like having too many cooks trying to prepare the same dish – it leads to chaos in the kitchen and on your website.

The Consequences of Keyword Cannibalization

The Dilemma of Diluted SEO Efforts

When a website indulges in keyword cannibalization, it’s akin to “eating its own SEO lunch”. This metaphorical expression captures how a site competes against itself in search engine rankings, particularly when multiple pages target the same or overlapping keywords.

The Ripple Effect on Key SEO Metrics

Keyword cannibalization has a cascading effect on several crucial SEO metrics:

  • Click-Through Rates (CTR) Get Divided: Instead of having one strong, authoritative page drawing in all the clicks for a specific keyword, the clicks get spread thinly across multiple pages. This dilution can significantly lower the CTR for each page.
  • Backlinks Lose Their Impact: Ideally, backlinks should point to a single, comprehensive page to enhance its authority. In cases of keyword cannibalization, these valuable backlinks are dispersed among several pages, weakening the overall link equity.
  • Content Value Gets Watered Down: When multiple pages vie for the same keyword, it’s likely that each page only covers aspects of the topic, leading to a dilution in content value. A single, well-rounded page usually provides more comprehensive information, thus holding greater value for users and search engines.

The Underlying SEO Problem

The core issue with keyword cannibalization is that it inadvertently creates internal competition among a website’s pages. This competition can confuse search engines and users alike, as it’s unclear which page should be prioritized for the targeted keyword.

Addressing the Issue

To rectify this self-competitive scenario, it’s essential to conduct regular content audits, identify instances of keyword overlap, and then take strategic actions like merging similar content, utilizing redirects effectively, and improving internal linking structures. It helps consolidate the SEO efforts towards one authoritative page rather than scattering them across multiple pages.

A Shoe Store Without Direction

Let’s take a hypothetical shoe store. If every page targets the keyword “shoes” without specificity, you ask Google to choose between your hiking shoes, tennis shoes, and sneakers pages for the same broad keyword. This lack of direction can be detrimental to your site’s overall performance.

Keyword Cannibalization.

Spotting the Cannibals in Your SEO Strategy

Identifying keyword cannibalization is a critical step in ensuring the health and effectiveness of your SEO strategy. It’s all about finding where you might unintentionally compete against yourself on the search engine results page (SERP). Here’s how to spot these cannibals:

Tools for the Hunt

Several tools can aid in this detective work:

  • Google Analytics: This tool is essential for tracking your website’s traffic and can help identify pages that might be competing for the same keywords.
  • SEMrush: A comprehensive SEO tool, SEMrush can provide insights into your keyword rankings and show where keyword overlaps might be occurring.
  • Ahrefs: Known for its backlink analysis capabilities, Ahrefs also offers features to identify keyword overlaps across your site’s pages.
  • Simple Site Search: Sometimes, the simplest methods are the best. Performing a search on Google (e.g., site:yourdomain.com keyword) can quickly show how often a particular keyword appears across your site’s pages.

Regular Content Audits

Regular content audits are essential to effectively spot keyword cannibalization. These audits involve:

  • Reviewing the keywords each page targets.
  • Analyzing the search intent behind these keywords.
  • Checking if multiple pages target the same or similar keywords and search intents.

Analyzing the Data

Once you have the data from these tools, the next step is to analyze it:

  • Look for multiple URLs ranking for the same keyword.
  • Check the SERP positions of these URLs – are they competing for similar positions?
  • Evaluate the content on each page to see if they serve the same purpose or answer the same user queries.

What to Look For

There are specific signs that indicate keyword cannibalization:

  • Fluctuating rankings for similar keywords across different pages.
  • Decreased traffic or lower conversion rates on pages that used to perform well.
  • Similar or identical keywords appear in different pages’ content, title tags, and meta descriptions.

Why Regular Audits Matter

Consistent auditing is key because your website is always evolving. New content is added, and search trends change. What might not have been a problem a few months ago could become a significant issue without regular checks.

A Woman In A Hijab Is Using A Laptop At Night To Fix Keyword Cannibalization Through Simple Steps.

The Recipe to Fix Keyword Cannibalization

Consolidate Similar Content

Merging similar pages into a single, comprehensive resource is a critical step in resolving keyword cannibalization. This process streamlines your content, making it more digestible for your audience and enhancing the overall user experience. It’s akin to creating a masterful dish that combines the best flavours from multiple recipes.

Multiple pages discussing similar topics or targeting the same keywords compete against each other for search engine rankings and user attention. Combining these pages creates a singular, authoritative source on the topic, which is more likely to rank higher in search engine results and provide more value to your readers.

Use Redirects Judiciously

Implementing redirects is like guiding your audience through a well-organized menu; you want to lead them directly to your best dish, not leave them wandering through a maze of similar options. Use 301 redirects to redirect less authoritative pages to your more authoritative ones. 

It tells search engines that the redirected page has permanently moved, consolidating the ranking power and clarity.

When you redirect a less authoritative page to a more authoritative one, you’re effectively consolidating the ‘SEO juice’ – such as backlinks and page authority – into a single, stronger page. This helps to enhance the page’s visibility and ranking in search engine results.

Employ Canonical Tags

Sometimes, duplicate content is necessary for business reasons or when content is repurposed across multiple platforms. In these instances, using canonical tags is essential. Canonical tags act as signals to search engines, indicating which page is the primary version should be indexed and ranked.

It is particularly useful when you have similar content that serves different purposes. For example, you might have a printable version of an article and the standard web version. Using a canonical tag, you can specify which version should be considered the ‘main’ page by search engines.

Re-evaluate Your Internal Linking

Internal linking is a powerful tool in your SEO toolkit. It’s like the signage in a restaurant – it should guide your visitors seamlessly to your best offerings. Ensure that your internal links point to your site’s most relevant and authoritative pages.

It involves analyzing your website’s internal link structure and ensuring that links point to the correct, authoritative pages. Doing so, you help search engines understand the hierarchy and importance of pages on your site, improving the chances of the right page ranking for a specific keyword.

The Power of the Single, Well-Seasoned Dish

In the world of SEO, sometimes less is more. A single, well-crafted page with consolidated power and clarity can outperform multiple weaker ones. Remember, in the kitchen of the internet, it’s not about how many dishes you have but how well each dish is prepared and presented.

Addressing keyword cannibalization is crucial for maintaining a healthy, SEO-optimized website. It’s about ensuring that each page serves a unique purpose and contributes to the overall dining experience of your site’s visitors. Regularly auditing your site for keyword overlap, consolidating content, appropriately using redirects and canonical tags, and maintaining a strategic internal linking structure will keep your site’s SEO performance robust and effective.

Frequently Asked Questions:

Can keyword cannibalization affect small websites?

Yes, even small websites can suffer from keyword cannibalization. It’s important for sites of all sizes to maintain a clear and unique keyword strategy for each page.

How often should I audit my website for keyword cannibalization?

Regular audits are crucial. Depending on the size and dynamics of your website, consider conducting an audit quarterly or bi-annually.

Is keyword cannibalization always a negative thing?

Generally, yes. While there can be scenarios where multiple pages rank well for the same keyword, this is the exception rather than the rule. It’s usually more effective to have a single, authoritative page per keyword.

Konger Avatar
4 months ago

Why Us?

  • Award-Winning Results

  • Team of 11+ Experts

  • 10,000+ Page #1 Rankings on Google

  • Dedicated to SMBs

  • $175,000,000 in Reported Client

Contact Us

Up until working with Casey, we had only had poor to mediocre experiences outsourcing work to agencies. Casey & the team at CJ&CO are the exception to the rule.

Communication was beyond great, his understanding of our vision was phenomenal, and instead of needing babysitting like the other agencies we worked with, he was not only completely dependable but also gave us sound suggestions on how to get better results, at the risk of us not needing him for the initial job we requested (absolute gem).

This has truly been the first time we worked with someone outside of our business that quickly grasped our vision, and that I could completely forget about and would still deliver above expectations.

I honestly can't wait to work in many more projects together!

Contact Us


*The information this blog provides is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as financial or professional advice. The information may not reflect current developments and may be changed or updated without notice. Any opinions expressed on this blog are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the views of the author’s employer or any other organization. You should not act or rely on any information contained in this blog without first seeking the advice of a professional. No representation or warranty, express or implied, is made as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this blog. The author and affiliated parties assume no liability for any errors or omissions.