Balancing Empathy and Sales: The Impact of Opt-Outs in Holiday Email Strategies

Balancing Empathy and Sales: The Impact of Opt-Outs in Holiday Email Strategies

Balancing Empathy and Sales: The Impact of Opt-Outs in Holiday Email Strategies

As Seen On

Balancing Empathy and Sales: The Impact of Opt-Outs in Holiday Email Strategies


Over the years, holiday and event emails have become a common component of most companies’ marketing strategies. With the increased prevalence of these campaigns comes an ongoing debate about their usefulness and potential pitfalls. This discussion is particularly relevant when it comes to sensitive occasions like Father’s Day. In this article, we will unravel the complexities of opt-out emails and discuss how businesses can strike a balance between empathetic marketing and the broader goals of their holiday campaigns.

Customer Reception of Opting Out of Holiday and Event Emails

A recent 2022 Capterra consumer study reveals interesting findings about how consumers perceive and interact with opt-out emails. According to the study:

  • 81% of respondents would purchase from brands that send holiday opt-out emails.
  • 68% believe that brands should prioritize consumer well-being over sales during holidays.
  • 39% always or usually opt-out from holiday and event emails.
  • 19% are personally sensitive to holiday marketing emails.
  • Generation Z and men are more likely to opt-out of holiday emails.

The study also indicates that the top opt-out events are Back to School and Valentine’s Day.

Holiday Opt-Out Emails as a Sign of Empathy

The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the importance of empathetic marketing for brands seeking to maintain strong relationships with their customers. By leveraging analytics and testing, companies can better understand customer preferences and tailor their holiday email strategies accordingly. This is particularly crucial considering the wide range of emotional responses that different holidays can elicit, such as Valentine’s Day post-breakup or Mother’s/Father’s Day after losing a parent.

Striking a Balance to Avoid Alienating Customers

To create thoughtful holiday and event emails without alienating customers, consider the following approaches:

  • Offer solid alternatives to holiday campaigns.
  • Use customer data to develop personalized, relevant content.
  • Segregate your audience based on preferences.
  • Comply with GDPR and prioritize consent.
  • Promote a sense of community, support, and well-being in your campaigns.

Analyze and Learn from Your Opt-Out Email Campaigns

Monitoring performance metrics is crucial for understanding the effectiveness of your campaigns. Employ A/B testing to assess various elements like subject lines, email design, and copy. Furthermore, track the reasons behind customer opt-outs to inform future campaigns.

Weighing the Pros and Cons Before Offering Opt-Outs

In today’s competitive market, customers increasingly expect brands to demonstrate empathy. Optimizing your holiday email campaigns based on data and testing is essential for incorporating thoughtful, customer-focused strategies. Ultimately, the responsibility falls on brands to prioritize consumer well-being over sales during the holidays.

By following the above recommendations, businesses and brands can successfully navigate the delicate balance between empathetic marketing and driving sales, leading to more effective and well-received holiday and event email campaigns.

Casey Jones Avatar
Casey Jones
12 months ago

Why Us?

  • Award-Winning Results

  • Team of 11+ Experts

  • 10,000+ Page #1 Rankings on Google

  • Dedicated to SMBs

  • $175,000,000 in Reported Client

Contact Us

Up until working with Casey, we had only had poor to mediocre experiences outsourcing work to agencies. Casey & the team at CJ&CO are the exception to the rule.

Communication was beyond great, his understanding of our vision was phenomenal, and instead of needing babysitting like the other agencies we worked with, he was not only completely dependable but also gave us sound suggestions on how to get better results, at the risk of us not needing him for the initial job we requested (absolute gem).

This has truly been the first time we worked with someone outside of our business that quickly grasped our vision, and that I could completely forget about and would still deliver above expectations.

I honestly can't wait to work in many more projects together!

Contact Us


*The information this blog provides is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as financial or professional advice. The information may not reflect current developments and may be changed or updated without notice. Any opinions expressed on this blog are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the views of the author’s employer or any other organization. You should not act or rely on any information contained in this blog without first seeking the advice of a professional. No representation or warranty, express or implied, is made as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this blog. The author and affiliated parties assume no liability for any errors or omissions.